
This painting was created by Todd Schorr. It is called "Clash of the Holidays"
Here are some "starter" questions to get ya going: What do you think about this painting? What do you think the message is? Why?
This is a forum for RELIC Participants to discuss ideas regarding religion, spirituality, faith, philosophy and any and all existentially related ideas. Each RELIC member must post twice a week to the initial blog posting (responding to the conversation as needed).
So...I definitely think that this is obvious symbolism of the fight over being the heavyweight of commercialized Christianity. The Easter Bunny and Santa Clause are going at it because they wish to be the "true" symbol of idealized and commercialized Christianity. I would like to think that the message is a cynical one, showing how the true meaning of these holidays have degraded over time due to media and monetary control from big corporations.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Marissa. If you look in the background of the picture, there are stereotypical symbols of our commercialized Christmas: Rudolph, the candy cane forest, Painted Easter eggs, etc. I think it is a commentary on the booming markets for both of these Christian holidays that has led both holidays far away from their original purposes and meanings. The terrifying and bloody baby Jesus noshing on a chocolate Easter bunny shows the perversion the Holidays have been through over time.
ReplyDeleteYeah, I think Savannah hit the nail on the head. We all know that the Christian holidays are on the days they are because Christianity took the pagan holidays and superimposed Christmas and Easter. It's a little bit of payback from the secular world, seeing Jesus thrown to the side with, as Savannah said, his image perverted. I guess the purpose was to highlight how the Christian holidays have lost their Christianity- I could think of other holidays that would be more likely to battle with Christmas for the commercialism crown.
ReplyDeleteThis is Addie Jo, if it doesn't show up as that. I need to change the name on my Google account for this email.
I really do find the baby Jesus in this picture to be particularly disturbing, mostly because it is the only clear religious symbol present in the entire picture. Of course, the other characters do have some religious symbolism, but baby Jesus is obviously religious in nature. I think it is interesting that baby Jesus is also snacking on a chocolate rabbit ear, which seems to symbolize that even the most religious part of the picture has given in to the commercial nature of these holidays.
ReplyDeleteBoth Easter Bunny and Santa Claus are recognized in Christian holidays. Basically they are all symbols in Christianity. The picture, I see, is Easter Bunny wants baby Jesus with it. I mean Easter Bunny want to be a symbol in December instead of Santa Claus. In the picture, the Easter Bunny is attacking Santa Clause, trying to be in the snowy land which represents the winter season.
ReplyDeleteWhen I look at this picture I am a little taken a back. This is an extremely violent picture. Obviously it is intended to depict the clash of holidays, but wow the blood dripping off of Santa's battle axe is too much. In our culture I think it is apparent that the over commercialization of these two holidays, has lead to people taking these kind of stances about their "favorite" holiday. I think that we should stop and research the holidays, and their historical background. That way we can better understand the symbolism that is depicted in our culture. The other thing I think these two are fighting over is money. I would love to see how much money is made off of these two holidays. Personally, I hate both of these holidays, they are both so over commercialized that it takes any legitimacy away from them. The only good thing that comes from easter is Cadbury Cream Eggs.
ReplyDeleteSo, I pretty much fall in line with everybody else's comments... commercialization, competition, baby Jesus... but what stands out to me the most is that nothing in this picture is attractive. Both the Easter Bunny and Santa Claus are scary looking, like the villans you have nightmares about; and the baby Jesus is scaring. If I just saw this picture, I wouldnt want to participate in either holiday.
ReplyDeleteI agree with what most everyone has already said about this post. The picture shows how the two holidays are are fighting between themselves. Both want to become the face of Christianity. It is interesting that there are no traditional religious symbols in here - no stars, no crosses, or other familiar symbols. It comments on how holidays have become commercialized to the point that they're hardly recognizable for their original meanings.
ReplyDeleteIt is amazing how people can create images like this and think of things like this. People can find other ways to point out holidays instead of violence and vulgarness! People should also take into respect other people's religions. I see a sign of hatred in this picture. I guess a great question would be, Why?
ReplyDeleteThis picture is trying to depict how religious holidays, especially christian holidays have become very commercialized. Industries have exploited days like christmas and easter and have turned it into a multi billion dollar industry. It's to the point where many people in our generation don't even know the significance of these dates, they just think of these days as gift giving days or days to feast. It's unfortunate because you have a religion like Judaism which is known for its cultural values and historical teaching, but then christianity has been turned into a product.
ReplyDeleteIn line with everybody else's comments, I also see this as a painting of the rise and battle of constant commercialization of the two "Christian" holidays, Easter and Christmas. On top of the obvious cultural symbols in the foreground, there appears to be a figure in the left background: some kind of fat, toad-like character in a top hat and with a sack of money by him. It looks as if he represents the CEOs and other executives who milk what they can out of the commercialization and just sit back and watch the clash as they enjoy the profits.
ReplyDeleteI agree that this image is clearly about the commercialism of Christian holidays. But I would like to ask if this is really a problem. What is wrong with a holiday being commercialized? Firstly, Christmas is often practiced by non-Christians; in fact it is a National Holiday. So in some ways Christmas is removed from it's religiousness, and I don't have a problem with that. I think there is something very beautiful about Christmas. Sure it has it's ugly parts, which are obviously represented in the above picture, but it stimulates the economy and unites a very individualistic society. I think in many ways Christmas is a secular holiday. I think the same of Easter, but I also think that Easter is much less commercialized for actual Christians. Especially because it's the major Christian holiday (much more important then Christmas). So basically I'm asking why is commercialization of a holiday wrong? I think cultures have been doing it for a long time. Just look at Rome and it's holidays and festivals.
ReplyDeleteThis picture is obviously a commentary on how so much attention is given to the cultural icons of Santa and the Easter Bunny on Christmas and Easter with little regard or attention to the actual supposed reason why these holidays are celebrated. My favorite part of this picture would actually have to be Mr. Chicken in the background with an utterly befuddled expression on his face. He has no idea why these two epic figures are fighting. He asks himself "Why?" This is extremely ironic because this big fat chicken symbolizes the CEOs who use these holidays to gain mass profits. It appears that he and others like him have created something beyond their control.
ReplyDeleteOne of the primary roles of art is to comment on the status quo and raise questions about our acceptance of it. This painting is extremely effective in this end as it makes us reevaluate something which we are probably extremely familiar. This painting, while having religious implications, deals mostly with things that appear in the secular sphere of each religious holiday. While Christmas celebrates the birth of Jesus (though probably historically out of season) a Baby Jesus can be included in the secular world because he appears in so many outdoor nativity scenes.
ReplyDeleteThis character image of Baby Jesus is fascinating because he may be considered a bastard of the two traditions being both a child (Christmas) and having a crown of thorns as well as, if you look very closely, a light beard (Easter)! He is being nourished by the fat of Easter Bunny's bounty and protected in Santa's snowy forest. It seems that this Jesus is gaining things from the holidays though he is less powerful and generally ignored. It raises the question: is this the sort of Jesus we want being fed?
Well, to being with, I'd have to say that I find this image rather grotesque. This is undoubtedly a fitting reaction as this piece is less art than it is a graphic statement on the degradation of Christianity's two main days of celebration. The dates no longer hold much of the same meaning as they did, and the artist suggests that the two holidays now compete to their mutual detriment. Unfortunately, while I certainly agree that the two days have suffered thanks to commercialism, I still believe that the two are capable to bringing families together, and therefore fulfill something of their original purpose.
ReplyDeleteI would describe the representation of baby Jesus here as a crack baby. He is clearly a product of his environment and the secular symbols of society. Abused, naked, and left out in the cold, he has turned feral. Welcome to the secularization of religion: The perversion of the original purpose of the remembrance by society may make it more palatable to the masses, but throwing a moralistic system like Christianity into a non-moralistic system like secularism (I am arguing that the essence of secularism is not moralistic), yields an enormous amount of friction, not just between Christians and non-Christians, but even among secular bodies. It is not clear what they are fighting about, but it IS clear that they are derivations of a religious remembrance, not even existing without the religion in the first place. My point? Their aimless fighting would never have existed without their derivation from Christian practices in the first place. Secularism created the struggle, and that could be anyone's blood on the end of the axe.
ReplyDelete