Monday, October 19, 2009

Week 8: Questions....

What are questions that you find yourself ruminating on? Ask them here and then have others discuss them.

(Questions can be on any religious or philosophical topic and can range among specific doctrines, natures, perspectives, interpretations, experiences, and so much more).

Ask one Question and answer one questions.

24 comments:

  1. How important are sacred writings to a person of any faith? As a consequence of that, how much should sacred texts affect a person's day to day life?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Why would a perfect God (perfect in the sense of complete and whole) want or need anything from human beings?

    ReplyDelete
  3. How much of religion is just a structure to help human beings tap into qualities that make for a functioning society? That is, how much is religion a vehicle for the propagation of social norms and functions? (If that makes sense. I hope it did.)

    IRT Addie Jo: Sacred texts are certainly great for helping people find inspiration in understanding their daily lives and their purpose; however, I feel that sacred texts should still be treated with a certain amount of distance and understanding of the context in which it was written and the differences between that time and now, so that the texts aren't applied literally and in a way that is detrimental (e.g. as a basis for prejudice).

    ReplyDelete
  4. Does free will exist if God already knows the choices we will make? And if so, does he actively try to intervene in these daily choices?

    ReplyDelete
  5. IRT Monica - For me (this is Jennie), I feel free will exists even if G-d knows the choice we will make. Like, just because he knows the choice, doesn't mean he makes it for us....(I am still working on why I think that). As far as intervening....well.... for now I've got nothin' on that one.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Why do religious leaders and followers tie themselves so tightly to religious texts? Is there something sacrilegious or blasphemous about using religious texts as guidelines instead of rulebooks? Why?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Savannah — If these religious leaders and followers really believe that their sacred text either came down from God or that they are inspired by God then it makes sense that they would want to be tied to them. If these texts explain how God wants them to live or how he designed life to be and supposing God wants good things for his creation, it seems logical to live according to the text.

    Religous texts as "guidelines" appears to imply that they are just suggestions that should be followed or disregarded. If adherents to a religious text only see the text as guidelines then they can choose how they feel is best for them to live, but, I would say, most of these people probably believe that God knows best. So, supposing God wants good things for his creation why would they want otherwise? Also, if these "guidelines" are disregarded then that person is making a statement by saying that he/she knows best and not God.

    Not all "religious leaders and followers" see/understand their text as a rulebook. Religious texts as "rulebooks" seems to imply that obeying a set of rules laid out by the text will merit God's favor or love. But not all religions would agree with the "rulebook" label. Biblical Christianity for example, would say (I hope) that right living (I am not saying someone who is not a Christian can't live morally) flows from your love for God/Christ and that you want to obey God because of His and your love for one another. A Christian should know that their performance will not cause God to love them more or less, but the evidence that someone is a Christian will be manifest in how they treat others, how they reflect Christ's love in serving others and through their obedience to God. Christ's love/Spirit must compel a Christian to live obediently and in sync with the Bible, otherwise trying to keep rules becomes drudgery and not joy.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Savannah -- I don't think it is necessarily blasphemous to use sacred texts more as guidelines, but I do think that Religious leaders tend to be conservative in their perspective faith for a reason. Institutions have a natural tendency toward their own self-preservation and as figureheads of their religious institutions they would rather not see people treating the basis of their faith as flexible.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I have been pondering the human imagination and where it comes from for a while. What exactly is it and how does it work? It isn't merely neurons acting in the brain. It's something much more unimaginable than that. But seeing that the imagination or divine inspiration is where many belief systems and religions come from, I think this is an important question.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I wonder why religion does not encourage us to question. Questions lead to thought, and thought leads to discovery.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Taylor I think wondering about questioning is a good pondering moment. I think though, that some religions do encourage questioning. Growing up in synagogue, it was always encouraged....

    Jonas...that is an excellent thought!

    ReplyDelete
  12. I know this is kind of late to ask question for this week. I hope someone could answer it for me. Anyway, my question is how can you strengthen your faith? or how can you convince yourself to believe that you have believed before?

    ReplyDelete
  13. IRT Andrew, I don't think there is significance in what you believed in the past, rather how strong your faith is at the moment. As to how you strengthen your faith is a difficult question to answer. I think just like history class or science class, when you hunger for more information you simply do more research, so with religion, if one is looking to strengthen their faith they should do more research. Whether it is through reading more sacred writings or listening to the sermons of a preacher, with more info comes more wisdom and even more assurance in what one believes.

    ReplyDelete
  14. IRT Will: Some would use this as an insertion point for the divine spark and, from what I understand of psychology and neuroscience, even if you boil it down to hard science we are still in awe and lack full understanding. While imagination seems too vast and rich to be a product of what is underneath hair, I think that it can be merely neurons; but there are miracles in the merely.

    IRT Taylor: I have wondered this several times myself. I think it is similar to why questioning is not always encouraged in school or in life in general. Sometimes people don't have the answers and they don't want to be embarrassed so they put the problem in the question. Sometimes it points out flaws. Sometimes it, as you pointed out, leads to discovery, but this discovery can be of other faiths. The religions that direct adherents elsewhere usually die out. The information being given could also be considered more important than an interrupting question. But some religious and denominations do actively encourage questioning.

    IRT Jonas: Brilliant question. You aren't asking to have never existed, but only to be set aside in the other realm. It depends on who you ask. Some would say that you can if you reach a certain state (Buddhists). Others would say no, that's just how it works (some Hindus). Yet others would say that your soul is unique and that you do not cycle more than once (the Apostle Paul).

    ReplyDelete
  15. How do we find meaning in what we do? We go here, there, sleep when we are tired, eat when we are hungry, but what drives us to do so ultimately? What ultimately give motion and meaning to our existence? Pleasure? Obligation? Curiosity? Love? Boredom? Faith? Purpose? What purpose?

    ReplyDelete
  16. And I love how no one has touched Joseph's question.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Alright here are my questions.
    What makes something moral or immoral?
    Is death vital to seeking truth and morality?
    Can God be evil? (Not is he or isn't he, but could he be)
    and
    "The secret source of humor itself is not joy but sorrow. There is no humor in heaven." by Mark Twain
    do you agree or disagree and why?

    ReplyDelete
  18. IRT Joseph:
    Maybe G-d is lonely or maybe G-d just wanted to create something beautiful.

    Those are all movie-esque answers....I will think about it more...

    IRT to Kim:
    That Twain reference made me a little sad... I don't know if I agree that the source of humor is sorrow. I understand the logic of the statement though... I think heaven would be hellish if there was no humor....I feel like that would be like a bad movie...like a continuous replay of the movie unbreakable (sorry Will).

    ReplyDelete
  19. How does one reconcile a conscious, omnipotent god with the existence of evil? Would not a god reminiscent of Spinoza's pantheistic deity make more sense given the condition of today's world?

    ReplyDelete
  20. IRT Jonathan IRT Will-- I think it's interesting that while you propose a scientific viewpoint, you still say that there are "miracles" in the merely... How exactly are you defining a miracle? To even admit that miracles can exist seems to be completely antithetical to a scientific defense of Will's question. Unless, of course, you are defining it differently.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Here is My question: Believing in no God has recently puzzled me: For instance, let's say you think Hitler was a bad person, evil, if you will. How do you defend that view without absolute morals? That is, America's morals (not killing Jews) are superior to the Nazis' morals (Killing Jews helps the human race overall) -- The thrust of my question is: How do you define things as good or bad, right and wrong, evil, justice, etc. without the presence of some sort of absolute authority to appeal to?

    How can anyone say- "it is right to help the poor," or "it is wrong to kill people you don't like." My response to you would be: who says?

    ReplyDelete
  22. IRT to Kimberly — Can God be evil?

    Can light ever shine as darkness?

    ReplyDelete
  23. Here is my question:

    I can follow the psychology of evolution (that is, why humans make decisions) all the way down to: I want to make more of myself...

    But my question is: why? Why do I want to make more of myself? What on Earth causes me to say, yes, this world in which people are born in pain, live in pain, and most often die in pain, this is the place that I would like to have a child in. I want to pass my genes off here. There seems to be a universal effort for replication...for what?

    Jonas,

    I wish I had read this earlier. But I would say simply to you probably what you have already heard a thousand times:

    yes. There is a way out of the cycle of birth and death. Christ, in giving his life, has given you the ability to not die but to be born again...you won't have to live out the death part again though, as you will have finally and permanently restored yourself with the God who satisfies all desires.

    Here's to hoping this reading is different! :)

    ---your roommate

    Jonas,

    Perhaps I have interpreted your question unlike everyone else. But

    ReplyDelete
  24. I think it would be really great if we all took a moment to appreciate an aspect of someone else's beliefs, what it has taught us, what truths it speaks about humanity, etc.

    ReplyDelete