Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
This is a forum for RELIC Participants to discuss ideas regarding religion, spirituality, faith, philosophy and any and all existentially related ideas. Each RELIC member must post twice a week to the initial blog posting (responding to the conversation as needed).
What I am prone to believe is that we evolved from a very distant ape-like ancestor, and over millions of years and through many gradual refinements humanity came into being. I do not believe any of the creation stories in religion, I feel like they are unreliable, inconsistent, and baseless because they lack proof.
ReplyDeleteI do not have a particular sense of how, why, or in what way we were created. I think this is one of the issues with which I continue to wrestle. This exact problem is what inspired me to ask my question that became the topic of last week's discussion. I believe, in some way, that God created the universe, but I am not sure why a perfect being would create at all. And so, I am led to believe that perhaps God (if God is an external being at all) is not perfect (again, I am using perfect in the sense of complete and whole). My point is that I am not really sure that a creation took place. I would compare here, but I really do not have a story to which I can compare because I do not know what my own view is yet.
ReplyDeleteI don't consider how we were created to be a philosophical question. Evolution via natural selection is the origin of the human species regardless of my philosophical opinion on the matter. Evolution has been observed in a laboratory setting. No amount of mental acrobatics can undo the overwhelming amount of scientific evidence.
ReplyDeleteThere is a bit of interesting overlap between the book of Genesis and science. We know now that the difference between entities is organizational. I.e. if the atoms that make me were arranged differently it would fundamentally change 'what' I am. There isn't necessarily a difference between the atoms in me and the atoms in dust; they are merely arranged differently to form cells, etc.
"And the Lord God formed man of the dust of the ground..."
Genesis 2:7
I'm not inclined to believe that either one of the traditional creation stories in Genesis is a literal truth about the creation of the universe, but I also know that there's limits to how far back science can go- even back to the Big Bang, there's a minuscule amount of time where we can't describe what happened in terms of today's physics (Planck time, for you cosmologists out there). So for me, picking any legend is just understanding that culture's values better. And the same thing can be said for us.
ReplyDeleteBut as for comparing creation stories, the Cherokee creation story is fun. Though it starts out with the animals making the world the way it is, instead of God, the explanation of why our lives are difficult is still the same- someone, somewhere, back in the day, messed up and now we all have to pay for it.
I believe in evolution. We are (or maybe just me) high thinking apes. If God created human, why God made chimps have slightly different DNA sequences to us? If God created human as his image, then he might have a lot of images. Clearly we are all different. If we had same common ancestors who are Adam and Eve, how did their children get married? Is that intermarriage? If so, then all of our DNA would be identical because there is no gene exchange at all. If not, don't tell me their children married someone else who were not related, then who were they? Did God create human before Adam and Eve? My point is God has nothing to do with human creation.
ReplyDeleteMy religion loosely follows the Adam and Eve creation story; however it is much more vague in how it is depicted(not like a story in which Eve bites the apple and then falls from grace. In my own personal opinion(believing in evolution), I think that G-d did create humans, however...there were steps along the way(aka what Andrew was saying about the chimps haha).
ReplyDeleteThis represents one of the fundemental questions. Science is at a loss to answer this question. "Evolution" doesn't cut it because you can always take it back and back until the Big Bang and nobody knows what that is. Religions try to answer it, but there are obvious holes in those explanations as well. So what created the Big Bang? It would be pretentious of me to claim I know, but here's one conjecture.
ReplyDeleteRather than the end of the universe resulting in an ultimate heat death where all matter and energy disappates into nothing like an Alkezelter tablet, I think the universe might end just like it began -- in a singularity like the big bang -- maybe it will collapse back in on itself and the whole process will start over again in a cycle. In other words the Big Bang has always been both the beginning and the end.
@Will.
ReplyDeleteEvolution is adequate to answer the question "how were we created." It does not answer the question "how was the universe created," but I don't see how that's relevant. Humans weren't present at the time of the Big Bang.
I.R.T. Corey: I was not aware that Evolution could be or has been observed in laboratory settings. Could you enlighten me as to this instance?
ReplyDeleteMy identification is that of an existentialist humanistic theistic romantic agnostic. This is a cumbersome and somewhat ridiculous label, but each part of this wordy set has meaning to me. For creation I generally appeal to what Science has to offer and though I have my own faint musings of how things came to be as they are I find the the Big Bang and Evolutionary theories both acceptable. The juiciest bite of my view on this is highly unsatisfying to others: the mystery. There is so much that I don't know and we may never know or understand and I'm pretty content with that--that's the romance of it.
For an alternate creation story, let's talk about Norse paganism. The earth as we know it was made of the left over parts of an immense frost-giant named Ymir who was killed by the young gods in a struggle. His blood became the sea, his bones rocks, his skull the sky, his brains clouds, and his hair trees as arraigned by the young gods. This is similar to a creation story from China. The first beings to be called human (not giants or gods) were crafted by the young gods from logs found by the sea shore. The young gods (three brothers) gave the couple life, consciousness, and speech respectively (with other attributes) and all other humans descended from these two. All of this has been highly simplified in the interest of brevity, and I encourage any and all to look over more of the myth. I found it and others at
http://www.gly.uga.edu/railsback/CS/CSIndex.html
so do check it out. I would like to point out that if Norse paganism is practiced, it is in the overwhelming minority despite its fascinating mythology. Also, creation stories are often not limited by religion but are divided by culture. An example of this would be the Japanese creation story.
While the Norse Creation may seem totally different from my beliefs, there are things to be found in common. Both represent an attempt to understand and account for the origin of humans and the earth (as do all creation stories) and both are particular to the world in which they were conceived. The first frost-giant (Ymir) was created by dripping ice--ice being readily available in Scandinavia and Northern Germany. It made use of that which existed in the world both physically and in terms of information: not only are there logs by the shore, but indeed things can be carved from these logs. My conception is similar in that it is based on physical surroundings (though less particular ones) such as the living matter and the cosmos, and available information such as popular theories of how species may change over time and how the universe might have initiated. If you took the time to read this, I hope it rewarded your interest.
IRT Corey:
ReplyDeleteWhat I meant is that while selective advantage over long periods of time could produce humans from apes, you still have to understand where apes come from to understand where we came from. You have to understand where life comes from and all the physical processes that lead up to it. I guess when I think of the question "How were we created?" I am interested in how events were set in motion that lead to life evolving humans.
I was always taught the simple christian story of God creating adam and eve, while in comparison there is the story of evolution. Both are incomplete, and vague so in a sense there could be legitimacy to either story. It's really hard to say if God's ultimate plan in the end was for us to start as simple microorganisms and then to finally evolve into what we are today.
ReplyDeleteAs an agnostic atheist, I suppose the creation story of my "religion" would be that of evolution, although I at times question basing atheism on science, as science itself still bases some of its theories on leaps of faith and gaps of knowledge. In any case, I believe it was Babylon that had the creation story where Marduk battles Tiamat and creates the world from her corpse. Like Corey pointed out, there's some overlap between these creation stories, which seem farfetched to us, and modern science: the notion of a preservation of matter, of creating one thing out of another, showing the universality of matter and the transitions from one form to another, which is similar to evolution, in an abstract way.
ReplyDeleteJohnathan,
ReplyDeleteWe can't copy and paste, but the article is "Bacteria make major evolutionary shift in the lab," by Bob Holmes in the New Scientist.
This sphere of existence is a level of samsara - the Buddhist word for the cycle of mundane existence of life that lacks true inherent purpose. The nature of samsara is suffering, everything is impermanent which suffers, gets sick, grows old and dies.
ReplyDeleteThrough the law of karma - the law that for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction - governs this cycle.
Therefore there wasn't a moment of creation - since beginningless time we have been in this cycle. Reincarnation is the belief that we have had multiple lives, a cycle of continuous rebirth and death that lacks freedom. We don't choose where we are born by making the conscious decision to be born into our family - rather our actions and the karmic retribution of our actions govern our life and experiences.
We are not helpless! The essence of enlightenment or nirvana is an existence outside the cycle of rebirth and death that is pure bliss and happiness. Each moment we can make the decision how to act, think, and speak; in turn we produce the karma - positive, negative and neutral, which dictates our life.
It is the simple concept of cause and effect. We do bad things, therefore our mind becomes disturbed and disillusioned, therefore we experience unhappiness. We do good things, our mind becomes clear and undisturbed, our mind finds peace and happiness. Eventually we can train our selves to do good things every moment, produce good karma, and hopefully eventually be liberated from samsara to enjoy the complete and full bliss of nirvana; a mind completely peaceful and happy free from all delusions.
I've always wondered about creation stories. What is there purpose in the sphere of religion and philosophy? You find creation stories in almost every single religion and ideology, from the Native Americans to Christians to Buddhists, etc. But why? My thinking is that one of the purposes of Religion is to explain the things that we can't understand, and the question of why we are here on this earth living and breathing is a HUGE question, and if you are to answer questions about this life then you had better prove your worth your salt by explaining why this life is here to begin with. However; I do believe in evolution, but i think that every creation story tells us something very important about life, and our approach to it. So, as a Christian I may not believe that the story of Adam and Eve is true in the literal sense; I do believe that it contains a deeper truth or key to truth that the real story of creation cannot.
ReplyDeleteWell, the religion I have most contact with is Christianity, so genesis is the "story" that I have heard and been taught. However, I grew up with professors - so the story of evolution is the story I was taught was correct. I don't know if I really believe that they have all the answers - that the soup analogy is completely correct (there are many things not explainable yet by this theory). I think its possible to believe evolution exists and also that everything could have evolved from beings God created. But overall, I'm okay not knowing how I got here, since I don't know where I'm going.
ReplyDeleteIf it is your philosophy and religion, the implication is that you agree with it. Unless you only nominally associate yourself with those beliefs. Or unless you pick and choose for situational convenience.
ReplyDeleteI am struck like Corey, by the similarities between evolution and the Genesis story.
God speaking "Let there be light," ...I could see that being the big Bang.
The creatures of the water being created first?
Man coming after all of the creatures of the land?
I am inclined to believe in an old Earth, as we didn't have a day or night till later (in biblical accounts).
I'm not quite sure, however, how macroevolution works, as all mutations would be genetic aberrations, and therefore more likely to die from the outset.
The creation story that I believe is from the accounts in Genesis, which I do think are metaphorical poetry. But I essentially believe that God was the creating force of energy that created the primordial sea, cause land to appears, animals and human to evolve and guided humans to become like him in that they can create, love, and plan to give him glory.
ReplyDeleteI read a native american creation story I really like where there were two gods who sat alone in the sky and anything they imagined would come into being. They thought of animals, mountains, trees and rivers, but they were not satisfied because none of these things really showed their skill or praised them for their creation, so they made beings of clay. The clay beings came apart when it rained, so they made beings out of wood, but they also cracked apart. Finally the coyote, parrot, crow and mountain lions aided the gods and they created humans.
What I like about this story is that the whole purpose of creating humans was so that humans could celebrate their own creation. Its really basic and positive, overshadowing suffering with the affirmation that we exist.
I believe that God created the universe and that he, too, created humans in His image. I am not too sure of the other creations stories but I have heard a little about the science and the big bang theory. The world and organisms are very specific and detailed matters so I do not believe that over time these organisms have just appeared on the face of the Earth. I believe that God create this universe with out-stretched and loving arms!
ReplyDelete