Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
This is a forum for RELIC Participants to discuss ideas regarding religion, spirituality, faith, philosophy and any and all existentially related ideas. Each RELIC member must post twice a week to the initial blog posting (responding to the conversation as needed).
I can honestly say that I have no clue how my philosophical perspective would justify war. When I say this I mean simply that I am torn. Part of me feels that war is the most horrible and unnecessary thing humanity has ever created, and that no war is just. The other part of me says, "There are things that are worth fighting for." I believe both sides to be true. The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan are completely unnecessary because they are unwinnable, and a waste of the U.S.’s resources. On the other hand though I fell wars like WWII were just and necessary wars. I am not even repulsed by the total war tactics that the allies used on Germany and Japan. Yes those tactics are brutal, but that is the way you win a war. According to my philosophical believes, in order for a war to be just you need to have an easily identifiable enemy whose proposes a real threat to not only your countries existence, but also your personal well being, and the well being of your fellow citizens.
ReplyDeleteHmm, well I believe that killing and harming is wrong. It's hard to justify killing any living being for any reason, including for food. Hence, most Buddhist, but not all, are vegetarians.
ReplyDelete"All forms of violence, especially war, are totally unacceptable as means to settle disputes between and among nations, groups, and persons." -His Holiness the Dalai Lama
I don't think we are wise enough to use violence without creating real determintal effects to the living. War causes death, it doesn't solve problems.
War is a negotiation. Our modern political ideas view the allocation and distribution of material goods to be a important area of concern for the state. If one nation state feels that the use of force is a less costly alternative to trade or diplomacy, war become a viable option.
ReplyDeleteIn my own philosophical thought, the question must be posed, what is best for the public good? If violence, cruelty, and war is best for the public then this course of action should be followed. If it is best for the public to be peacable then a peaceful existence should be followed. A contemporary example are the failed states (like Colombia, Somalia, and Afganistan). In these states a government must use a heavy hand and commit acts of war against subversive actors to restore order which will lead to the future improvement in the life of the citizen (the most common type of war today is civil war, not inter-state war).
I actually found out today that the Methodist Book of Discipline, which is kinda like our bylaws, states that military service is against Christian teaching. Clearly, Christians have had to justify war and I'm sure there are verses in the Bible that can be skewed to say whatever you want them to, just as verses in any other holy book can be used to support almost any idea or agenda.
ReplyDeleteReally, I deplore war and I wish that Christianity would be a religion of peace, but I understand that it is a political reality of today and I support the men and women brave enough to serve their country and her leaders. As CS Lewis said, "Do not let us mistake necessary evils for good."
I do not think there is an official stance on war shared by all Christians, so I will tell you what I really think. I think there is a case for a Christian to go into the armed forces if they feel called to that career. If you read the book of Psalms, it is clear that God uses the suffering that David goes through to glorify Himself.
ReplyDeleteThe bible doesn't teach that anyone should seek to harm others, actually the opposite, that you shouldn't demand punishment when people wrong you because you have been forgiven for literally every sin you will commit in your life.
As I don't belong to any religious group or philosophical system that speaks on the matter of war, I suppose I am limited to my individual perspective.
ReplyDeleteI don't believe that one should initiate war unless doing so is absolutely necessary for the survival of one's own nation or the survival of another. It is also reasonable to defend one's own nation against an aggressive power. Starting a war to defend an ideology or when doing so is little more than an essentially emotional or moral obligation is generally unrealistic and counterproductive in the modern political environment. Also, leaders should not rely upon the sentiments of the public when deciding policy in this area.
Although I am in the midst of a religious search at the moment, I remember a passage from the Bible that always helped me when thinking about issues like this. It is from Ecclesiastes 3 and states:
ReplyDelete"There is a time for everything,and a season for every activity under heaven" and several verse down it mentions "a time for war and a time for peace".
I guess that, for me, war seems to be inevitable in some way. I think it is terrible and awful, but I don't think that we humans are far enough along in our development to stop using it as a way of achieving certain ends.
Although I am catholic, in the bible there really isn't a specific doctrine prohibiting the use of war. I am not deeply religious, instead I use religion as a guide to accomplish my daily goals. One example I feel is relevant to this post is the story of Alvin Yorke, one of the greatest war heroes in American history who almost never came to be because he felt his christian background which discouraged warfare and violence. After entering the battlefield he simply accepted his fate and trusted that God was on his side. Perhaps in a similar fashion is the Baghad Vita, were Arjuna feels complicated about fighting in a battle where he will be up against his own family members. Eventually Lord Krisna asserts him of his duties and a central part of the text is how one must complete their actions without considering self interest. So in essence although war may be perceived as evil or unnecessary, it is perhaps something needed in order to maintain the greater good of society and that in itself justifies wars as a means to accomplish world order.
ReplyDeleteWar is justified under what I guess can be called my "philosophical perspective."
ReplyDeleteWar is unfortunate and it doesn't benefit anyone to pursue it without exhausting peaceful means, but I am not a pacifist. In the United States we have an established way of life and sometimes we have to protect it with violence. We tend to ignore that much of the world is practically enslaved simply so that we can enjoy chocolate or shoes at a reasonable price. Yet we get squeamish if we have to defend serious affronts to our safety. At some point we simply have to decide whether or not our political and economic system is worth preserving and live with the reality that sometimes preserving it means destroying something else if they are mutually exclusive.
Some people are only open to certain types of war, like self-defense. This isn't the case for me. The implications of what I said above are that I am also fine with preemptive war and covert operations as long as it is seriously based on our best intelligence. Here's an example of what I mean, Operation Orchard in 2007:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Orchard
I think that Operation Orchard is justified even if there were not actually nuclear weapons present AND a significant number of civilians died AND it breaks international law (all of which might be true).
Movements like Gandhi's or MLK's could never work in a country like North Korea or Iran. They did work under the governments of the United States and Britain because those countries had attained a level of moral "progress" and understanding different from the countries previously stated. But these countries manifested from a long history of violence and war so can we really separate the ideals of pacifism and violence? Unfortunately for mankind, the peaceful have often been destroyed by the violent because this behavior is a system we inherited from primates. With this being said, if you are forced to make the decision between all good being destroyed or destroying some good in order to save some good, what is the justified decision? WWII I believe is the war which came closest to being justified in human history, but most wars are obviously not justified. Unfortunately, while I believe human beings should strive to evolve a higher ideal, I still recognize that human civilization as a whole still lives under the paradigm of physical force.
ReplyDelete