Monday, October 26, 2009

Week 9 - Taken from your Questions

This question was taken from your list of fascinating questions. It was posed by Joseph.

"Why would a perfect God (perfect in the sense of complete and whole) want or need anything from human beings?"

24 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I feel that if there is a perfect God, he would want us to be just like him. He then gives us a moral code to follow so we can know his ways. I feel like this question is easily answerable if we think about it in the context that God created us. If he took the time to create us, then he must be interested in seeing good come of us. Therefore, he needs something from us because he has something invested in us.

    ReplyDelete
  3. When questioning God's motivation in creating human beings, I can never find anything more than pure selfishness in the act. Lacking existence prior to creation, humanity could not have possibly desired consciousness, so the act of bestowing it seems entirely self-gratifying. This, of course, is rendered irrelevant if God is indeed an unconscious aspect of existence and therefore beyond need or desire.

    ReplyDelete
  4. One interesting thought experiment which receives more attention in the eBook God's Debris goes as follows: If an omniscient and omnipotent God exists then what would be the only challenge to said God? One answer would be self-destruction. Would God be able to destroy himself if he was all-powerful and would he know what would happen after wards? The thought experiment goes on to describe the scenario of God's self destruction: The Big Bang. Every bit of matter and energy down to it's infinitesimal elementary particle is literally a particle (debris) of God which (given infinite time) is trying to reconvene itself back into omniscience and omnipotence -- hence the evolution of matter and life into higher states of complexity and consciousness over time(from amoeba to Einstein). So with this view, humans are just a part of God which makes up the whole of the universe. A bit strange to fit into a paragraph, but I think this is an interesting point of view.

    ReplyDelete
  5. A common answer to this question is God's loneliness and desire for company, entertainment, return of love, what have you. But if God is complete unto himself, there is nothing he could possibly need or want from us. To say that a perfectly whole being would need anything from anything outside itself is contradictory logic. He might be interested in our doings as we are his creations, but the question of why he created us in the first place remains a mystery.
    IRT Matt: What you say depends on how you view consciousness. God may have bestowed consciousness on lifeless matter as a gift to it, rather than as an act of self-gratification. But this gift idea implies that consciousness is good. That's another discussion entirely, but this small change in perspective gives us something to think about.
    IRT Will: I find this idea fascinating. It is a big happiness which fills me when I encounter perspectives in cosmology which I had previously not considered. It does imply that God, through struggling, is now less than omnipotent.

    ReplyDelete
  6. What I want to know is who created God?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Oh snap Taylor! I'm trying to decide how to respond to that question. It is almost like asking who started time during our lives, but most people would have the convenient answer of God for anything they would ask. Generally I accept that things are cyclical on the large scale, rather than linear. I'm not sure if that does anything for you. Infinity is a large idea.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hmm. It's a hard question to answer without making God too much like us. An all-powerful god wouldn't need anything from us certainly, and a complete god wouldn't want anything from us, reasonably, but that's just because we don't know what it's like to be complete. We always want something, sometimes we need something. And if we say we're completely happy and couldn't want anything else in the world, we belittle everything we don't have, like it couldn't possibly be important enough to want. Maybe the answer is that we're not important enough to want, but God, illogically, does anyway. I mean, God's supposed to be the best of everything, so He should make the most sense, but I don't know that He has to.
    IRT Taylor: If God is infinite, He's always been, so there's no creating involved. There was never a first moment for someone to create Him. He just always was. But if God's not infinite, you don't get out of the question so easily.

    I'm really interested in this idea of God being internal. Does anybody know who first proposed it or if there's a history to it?

    ReplyDelete
  9. IRT, Addie Jo

    God has just always been? There had to be some point where he came into being. There had to be some combination to spark his conception.

    ReplyDelete
  10. If God existed, I think God created human due to his boredom. Human lives are just like a game to God. God can make whoever live or die. God can decide everything.

    ReplyDelete
  11. IRT, Taylor Gilleland

    There doesn't necessarily have to be a point where God came into being because that would be limiting the manifestation of God to 4-dimensional space-time. Humans by design cannot comprehend infinity. God is both the beginning and the end. Nothing and everything. Renaissance Alchemists called this the "Coincidencia Oppositorum" -- the union of opposites. The ultimate truth is both what it is and what it is not. This is hard to make sense to us because we can't really comprehend higher dimensions but it would be similar to a being who lives in two dimensions traveling around a globe or a sphere -- he would start out seemingly going in a straight line but would eventually end up where he started -- he wouldn't be able to figure it out.

    ReplyDelete
  12. If God is not eternal, then someone created him.

    Someone else had to create the creator of God ad infinitum.

    So there cannot be a beginning to this creation.

    If you can accept that there is never a beginning to this creation then you must also be able to accept that God can be eternal.

    Thus there cannot be a point where he came into being.

    So God is eternal (he was not created).

    ReplyDelete
  13. I like what Tyler said. God has created us and I believe that there should be good that comes out of us. We do slip and fall because we are sinful; there not perfect. I believe that we should give God praise and thank Him for all that He has done for us. He has provided his Son for us so that we can be free from sin and saved. It is just for us to thank him and love him. Another said something along the lines of... "We love Him because He first loved us."

    ReplyDelete
  14. Maybe a perfect and complete deity doesn't need anything from us at all, and laughs at us for our misguided efforts to worship it. Perhaps this hypothetical deity would rather us put our human efforts into taking care of each other.

    ReplyDelete
  15. "Why would a [complete and whole] God want or need anything from human beings?"

    This is another question that only really makes sense within a literalist's interpretation of God.

    If "anything" is an object then the question is a little bit weird--why would god want my watch? Or why would god want a sacrifice, like a lamb or a virgin? Most people don't believe he wants things like that (anymore), so I don't think that's the question.

    The better question is why does god prescribe actions? Why does he want me to do certain things--not sacrificing a lamb but sacrificing a Sunday morning.

    Seen in that capacity, the question is pretty easy to answer; god doesn't want things from us because he needs them, he wants us to do certain things to prove ourselves.

    For example, if I say my coach WANTS me to show up to practice, it's not because he requires it to survive, as in the way I WANT food. I'm doing it to prove that I can play. Similarly, god wants me to do good actions so that the Archangel Michael will deem me worthy of heaven on judgment day, or whatever your respective religious tradition teaches.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I think that this question is a bit too philisophical for the purposes of RELIC but I think that this question is a bit leading.

    I don't presume to know why a perfect God would care about us because I am not sure what perfection is or what a perfect entity would be like. A perfect entity could be considered so becuase it needs us or because it doesn't need us. It's very difficult to even address the question because the idea of "perfect" is so subjective.I think that people in religions don't question why God loves them, but rather seek refuge in the fact that he does love them.

    ReplyDelete
  17. IRT Corey, I agree somewhat with the changes that you make to the question. It is strange to say that God wants or needs physical things from people; although I do not believe this is a totally foreign idea in modern religious thought. I have been to places of worship where the head figure claims that God wants money to assist with the building of a center or a new place of worship, but I think that has more to do with what people perceive from particular faiths rather than the idea of God in general.

    I worry about your objection because you say that "God doesn't want things from us because he needs them, he wants us to do certain things to prove ourselves". The reason I do not think this is a full response is because my question allows that God does not need anything from us. God can "want or need". So then , I agree that we can rule out that God needs something from humans, but I am still puzzled as to why God would want anything (actions, etc.) at all.

    For example, the coach in your example wants you to show up so that you can practice. Now, you are right that the coach does not need you to show up, but he still wants it, which implies a lack. He "wants", and that means he does not have whatever your showing up to practice would grant him, be that happiness, satisfaction, or just a sense of accomplishment. In what way can God want unless God also lacks in this same way? You said that God wants us to prove ourselves so that we can get into heaven or something along those lines. My question is then, what does God receive from seeing that accomplishment that God does not already have? It cannot be happiness, satisfaction, or a sense of accomplishment, because God already has all of those things. Indeed, God has them to the maximum that anyone can have them because God is perfect. And so, I do not think that God wanting us to prove ourselves has completely addressed the question in a satisfactory way. Please respond if you want to because I would love to keep this going :)

    ReplyDelete
  18. Apparently you can't copy and paste, so I'm not going to respond to any particular part of your post in detail.

    @ Joseph: Basically what you're saying is that you don't like that I'm reformulating the question. At least I think that's what you're saying, to be honest I don't quite understand your second paragraph.

    The question is basically "why would a god who doesn't need anything need anything?" There's no good answer. The only way that it makes sense is if you change need to want and assume that god wants us to do things purely for our own benefit.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Although God may be complete, we aren't and he although he doesn't need anything, for people who believe in God they are in need of him. God never really asks anything us, He simply wants us to live a pure life with morals and to be able to be as complete as he is. However this isn't something that is simply accomplished, which is why there is a need for people of religion for God, however the same is not true vice versa.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I actually find myself agreeing with Andrew's comment. I'm at the point where, were I to believe in a god, I would believe that s/he has a sense of humor, one that human beings can't quite understand. I feel that humans were created as an experiment to see the extent of creation and destruction that living beings can do and the extent of human creativity in helping and harming others. Kind of like a reality TV show for God, if you will. Perhaps I'm anthropomorphizing God too much, but that's how I feel at the moment.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Wow Will, really interesting perspective on the question! My own personally philosophy shares some truth of that view point.

    Personally, if God exists he is so infinite that he can't be described with insignificant humans and their language. I believe that what one could consider to be God is in fact the entirity of the universe in all its complex beauty and intricacies. Therefore we are included in this definition of God - we have the infinite potential of compassion, love, kindness, and purity that we believe God to be. What else is God but an abstraction of all that we think is holy and good? Therefore God is within our own mind and to truely discover God is train our mind and discover our own potential infinite holiness.

    In Buddhism we refer to this infinite potential of purity, goodness, compassion, etc as a Buddha. An enlightened being that can see the true nature of all existence. We ourselves have the potential to become a Buddha. That is one of the major pillars of the Buddhist faith - taking refuge in the Buddha Jewel; beleiving that all sentient beings, including ourselves, have this potential as well. We cultivate this Buddha nature through meditation, practicing moral discpline, engaging in good works of generosity, patience, kindness, etc.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I'm not sure of what your definition of complete is here, but I don't think of God as simply an external entity, but as also what makes up every other thing in this universe; So, in that sense he doesn't want anything but himself, and we are a part of his self; therefore, he desires us as well. But like Addie Jo seemed to be saying, the idea of 'complete' is so foreign I can't even get my head around it.
    But, I really liked Will's thought experiment about self-destruction. It's fascinating.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I like that idea: that since we are a part of God's creation we are a part of himself, and therefore he desires himself (us).

    I don't particularly find anything wrong with God desiring himself. Or a "selfish" God. Everything exists for God, and when everything gives itself to God, it has fulfilled its purpose.

    That is our job as creations: to fulfill our purpose. If my shovel refuses to dig, and instead desires to be a rake, what do I have? I have a useless piece of creation not living up to its original purpose. If I want to dig a whole, I will probably find a shovel that can dig.

    Also, I think that if we define God as Love, then we must also define objects for love.

    ReplyDelete
  24. It doesn't really matter, God can do whatever he wants. Just by acknowledging their is an all powerful perfect God, you are negating the validity of questioning why he does things.

    ReplyDelete