Monday, November 16, 2009

Week 12 - Healthcare

How does your philosophical and or religious perspective shape your understanding of/opinion about the Healthcare Bill. (If you need to, you can read about it here. In this story there is a PDF to the actual Bill...its long)?

18 comments:

  1. I feel it should be the right of everyone to have free health care. I think that it is a moral obligation that we owe not only to ourselves, but to our fellow countrymen as well. Taking care of the sick, the needy, the poor, the tired, and the hungry are all part of my religious/philosophical beliefs. Morally, I feel like I have an obligation to the health of others, I also feel that if this country wants to ever be a truly great country health care is an issue that must be tackled, no only for the moral issue, but for the economic problems that our current system has put us in.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with Taylor in that healthcare is a right that everyone should be entitled to. I also feel that from a moral standpoint it was the right thing to do to omit the coverage of an abortion in cases that are not deemed to be a risk to ones health. People shouldn't be forced to fund something they are morally against and they shouldn't be forced to fund the poor decisions of others.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Morally, abortions are the only option.

    Most of us have heard about the decrease in crime during the 90s, which was totally unexpected. Up until that point crime, especially violent crime, was on the rise. The decrease in crime wasn't because of tougher law enforcement, it was because of abortion, which was legalized in the seventies, about 18 years before the decrease in crime.

    Why? Because the kids who were being aborted are exactly the ones who were the most likely to commit violent crimes. The states that legalized abortions the earliest saw the earliest reductions in crime. The states that performed the most abortions saw the greatest reduction in crime.

    Please check behind me on this one. Do a google search for "Steven Levitt, abortion, crime." The first thing that comes up is a PDF entitled "The Impact of Legalized Abortion on Crime," written by an economist from the best university in the country for Econ, University of Chicago, published in the Quarterly Journal of Economics. Check it out. Click on my name for the link.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Free health care to everyone is a great idea. However, who is everyone? Should we set free health care to people who are not able to work or to people who are poor and lazy, living by social welfare? I don't mind to pay tax to give free health care to handicap people, but I do mind to give free health care away to the poor and lazy one. If people had free health care and social welfare, do you think those people would try to keep staying poor or to work their way up to get out of poverty? I think they would try to keep staying poor. I believe no one wants to go to work since they have social welfare and free health care. That the reason I am struggling with my mind right now for this problem.

    ReplyDelete
  5. There's definitely room for discussion on this topic and one of my favorite things about my faith and my denomination is that you can be on either end of the political spectrum and not be against church doctrine. I believe that we should help those who cannot help themselves, but the specifics of that are more complex, like all the previous posts indicate. And we've brought up some interesting points, though I have to say that I disagree with the idea that abortion is a great thing. It's true, I agree, that the children most likely to be aborted are the ones that commit violent crimes, but I am hesitant to say that that's reason enough to make it legal, even encouraged, and I'm pretty sure that I don't want to pay for someone's poor decision. But this is all my personal opinion and I'm glad I'm entitled to it.

    ReplyDelete
  6. "I'm pretty sure that I don't want to pay for someone's poor decision."

    Would you be willing to stand behind this for other medical procedures? Let's say we have universal health care and I get cancer because I chose to work at a job that puts me at risk. Or I get lung cancer because I smoked. Or I get hit by a car because I crossed the street when I wasn't supposed to. Or I have a heart attack at 50 because I didn't work out enough.

    Should health care not cover this stuff?

    On the one hand, if we didn't cover ANYTHING that was preventable it would save a lot of money. Very few health problems are totally unpreventable. On the other hand, it makes us look pretty barbaric. I suppose I'm a little less comfortable than you are letting people writhe around on the street post car-collision because society doesn't want to pay for their "poor decision."

    And finally, speaking of "poor decisions," if we try to prohibit abortions by not making them a part of health care, people are going to pay with their lives. Again, abortions save real, living, breathing people because they reduce violent crimes.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Wow, I'm glad this conversation is completely non-controversial.

    ;)

    I'm honestly not sure how I feel about health care, mostly because I don't understand the economics behind it. I think most of the debate over health care so far has been pure noise - people shouting about socialism versus people shouting about how it is heartless, soulless, and barbaric to not have universal health care. What I'm concerned about is the cost and the impact it will have on the economy, and I haven't really spent much time trying to assess any of that. Honestly, my religion doesn't have much impact on my views of health care, because I don't know what my views of health care are yet - I haven't checked the numbers. I definitely think we should take care of our fellow human beings, but we also have to be realistic about making policy.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I think the question of health care for everyone isn't a question that should of religion, but of the state. The statue of liberty's inscription says:

    Give me your tired, your poor,
    Your huddled masses, yearning to breath free,
    The wretched refuse of your teeming shore,
    Send these, the homeless, tempest tossed,
    I lift my lamp beside the golden door.

    We should make health care affordable for everyone - not free for everyone - but affordable. By doing this we have given them an opportunity at a better life through the "golden door" that is America.

    Beyond that, I think that morally, as Americans, we should help each other out. We should band together because the republican idea that "it's every man for himself and no one's going to help you out," is isolating for individuals in a population of people that could be so connected by their differences. We should all work hard and do our part - yes, there will always be that freeloader not doing his or her part - but we should work hard to do our part for others, without worrying what we get out of it, what WE are going to receive. Sometimes its just about a little compassion. Without compassion, society's a flop.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Overall I don't really see an issue with abortion itself, I just feel that abortions are procedures that can potentially be avoided all together and not enough is being done to prevent it. I feel not enough funds and not enough schools provide the proper sex education necessary that could educate students on how to prevent themselves from being put into a situation where they would need an abortion. I would feel much better about including abortion coverage as part of the healthcare bill if more was being done to educate individuals on how to prevent themselves from being put into that situation in the first place.

    In response to Andrew's comment, I'm surprised that you hold such views against those who are on social welfare. Much of what you are saying is based around negative stereotypes that are simply untrue. While some people do abuse the system, for many welfare is a necessity. Just because people poor and less fortunate does not make them lazy, nor does it mean they aren't hardworking individuals who are striving to better themselves. In addition, I don't think anyone who is poor likes being poor and wants to stay poor simply because they are being provided with a few services such as foodstamps and medicaid that allow them to survive. Lastly, should the U.S. implement a system of Universal Health care, its a system that should provide services for all legal residents. One of the great things about this country is that we don't discriminate simply based on your social status. It wouldn't be feasible, nor would it be just to implement a system of healthcare and exclude individuals just because they are deemed as too poor and lazy by your standards.

    ReplyDelete
  10. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  11. There was a great string of letters in the DTH today that had to do with the abortion in healthcare issue. A lot of people argue that they shouldn't be forced to pay for abortions because they're morally against it—yet, as the letters brought up, a lot of us (myself included) are pacifist and are morally against wars; a number of people are also morally against the death penalty. Yet these are things that we are still paying for with taxes. What about our morals regarding those topics, then? What makes this moral issue so different? It's an argument to the fetus's right to life, yet, at the same time, many who espouse this "pro-life" view still continue to turn to wars and capital punishment, which only result in death—sure, you could say that you're saving future lives, but people still end up dead from these actions. To me, that's contradictory, and the issue with abortion often ends up being not an issue of the fetus's life, but about the position of women in society and how much power is given to women (or not). Personally, I feel that, if you're going to make a big fuss over a fetus's right to life, you damn well better see to it that the rest of the fetus's life—not just its birth—is going to be just as protected and cared for.

    As for healthcare as a whole, I haven't given it much thought. Atheism and agnosticism don't deal in particular with these kinds of issues directly. And if we go off of Qoheleth/Ecclesiastes, which is beginning to have a greater influence on shaping my worldview, everybody's going to die anyway. So if we take another step back and view the world objectively, we realize: The world is overpopulated. Why improve healthcare at all? Why try to delay the forces of death? Why do anything to sustain and increase populations; why stop anything that's decreasing populations?

    Yet, at the same time, just because everybody's going to die doesn't mean that we should just sit back and let it happen anyway–as a friend said when I brought up this viewpoint to him, "Individuals matter." I wouldn't jump right in and call myself a humanist (because of contentions with ideas of universalism in the philosophy, which I won't go into here), but I do believe that people have the ability to help each other, care for each other, and improve the state of humankind as a whole. Therefore, despite the knowledge that everybody's going to die anyway, I still believe that we should make an effort to improve the quality of life of those who are less fortunate than we are; if we have something to offer, we should give instead of hoarding. So, in the end, despite my atheist agnostic background and a pretty cynical view of the meaning of life (there is none—therefore, you must construct your own meaning out of the inherently meaningless stimuli you're given), my viewpoint on this pretty much ends up being very similar to Abrahamic viewpoints. I don't have enough background with other viewpoints to say whether or not mine ends up being in line with theirs, though.

    ReplyDelete
  12. The previous comment that was removed was just the same comment; I deleted it to make some minor adjustments. Just to clarify.

    Steven – At the same time, there are a lot of forces that are also at work that are separate from just sex education. There's still the difficulty of accessing birth control/contraceptives, particularly in lower income brackets, where people simply have fewer resources. These resources include transportation to get to and from places where birth control and contraceptives are dispensed, as well as even access to a doctor who can write a prescription for hormonal birth control or some other harder-to-access form in the first place. Plus the income to spend on these needs anyway, if the costs aren't covered by the state or by the providing institution. And then there are things like social stigmas against BC/contraceptives, ranging from individual attitudes (e.g. guys who refuse to use condoms because they assert that it reduces sensation) to broader societal attitudes (e.g. in some groups, the idea that a woman carrying condoms isn't to be respected). So while awareness is one important part of it, there are other factors to be taken into consideration. In conclusion, I agree regarding your second comment; I just think the scope of focus should be broader. As for your first comment, see below for my response to Addie Jo.

    Addie Jo – For many of the reasons I mentioned to Steven, I hesitate to conflate "abortion" with "poor decision". There are just so many factors that weave into reproductive rights that it would be impossible to categorize them all as "poor decisions"; I'm sure that a number are, but so many other cases are far more complex than that. Which isn't to say that we should absolve people of responsibility, but that personal responsibility isn't the only factor in this picture, and saying that somebody just made a poor decision could very well be just a distancing mechanism so that we don't have to feel a sense of responsibility for them or helping them. I'm not saying that that's what you're doing; it's just a possibility.

    Andrew – Your views are a lot like my parents'... Again, like what I said in the above two replies, there are far more social factors than just personal agency that play into poverty, as well.

    Corey – I really like your comments. That's all. :)

    ReplyDelete
  13. I feel like Universal Health care should be a priority of a government which claims to serve the people. The amount of uninsured people in this country is scary. I feel like there should be some level of moral obligation to alleviate this. Just think how much money we have spent in Iraq and other places that could have been spent trying to develop a decent health care system. However, I don't think this will be an easy issue to solve, especially now. I don't have a very good understanding of the Health Care Bill or what its implications will be or even whether or not it will make things better or worse in the long run.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I thought it would be reasonable to spell out how the media is reporting on the Heath Care Bill before answering this question:

    "It provides coverage for 96 percent of Americans. It offers everyone, regardless of health or income, the peace of mind that comes from knowing they will have access to affordable health care when they need it," said Rep. John Dingell, the 83-year-old Michigan lawmaker who has introduced national health insurance in every Congress since succeeding his father in 1955.

    United in opposition, minority Republicans cataloged their objections across hours of debate over the 1,990-page, $1.2 trillion legislation.

    "We are going to have a complete government takeover of our health care system faster than you can say, 'This is making me sick,'" Rep. Candice Miller, R-Mich., said of the bill, adding that Democrats were intent on passing a "jobs-killing, tax-hiking, deficit-exploding" bill.

    -abc.com


    Wow well while searching the web what I really found much of the coverage about the Health Care Bill was not the the benefits or cons to the bill, but rather a loud argument between two bitter American political parties. I think very few people - the experts - really know the full extent that this health care bill will have on the life of every American citizen.

    Considering this, I think that its obvious that this issue is really between systems of power and control within the government.

    Personally, I think that since we are the most developed country that doesn't have a nationwide healthcare system, and that we spend the most the most money on health care, and we are ranked 37th in the world for health care, it would be our benefit to spend a little more money now to help more people in the long run. Especially since we are already trillions of dollars in debt, I fully support spending more money on an issue that will help the majority of the country rather than spending more money we don't have on something pointless like pork and barrel spending or military funding.

    Stephany I agree with you on many of your points! Life is pointless cycle of suffering unless we transform it into an opportunity to help others; which we can with this health care bill.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Well, I do not think that my faith really supports any view on healthcare. If God does exist, then I do not think he/she/it really cares what we do. So that is left up to us.

    That being said, I think that there is good reason to exclude some, though not all abortions, from the healthcare bill. It seems necessary to me that the bill cover abortions that would save the mother's life or that are otherwise medically necessary; however, it seems very different to me to say that we should cover all abortions. Not all abortions are medically necessary. I would not support a bill that covered plastic surgery for personal reasons or other surgeries or procedures that are not critical to the life of the patient. And yes, I get that most people are going to say that pregnancy is critical to the quality of the life of the patient, but abortion is still an elective procedure, and one that a doctor will recommend only if the life of the individual is in danger. Thus, I think there is good reason to exclude some abortions from the healthcare bill.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Jesus is about people. More specifically: people helping other people. I want you to be able to get the healthcare you need when you get sick. I want you to be physically ok. I hope we can find a way to do this. I hope people see Christ through out actions. Take my money, it was never mine in the first place. I trust my creator to give me all that I need.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I disagree, Jonas.

    I feel that I have my morals in line. I do not have a problem aborting violent criminals in an effort to make society more cohesive. Since there is no universal moral code, I think the best option is a utilitarian perspective.

    If we truly implement utilitarianism, we should expand abortion past the first trimester to the age of 5, and then after the age of 85. This is especially the case if we implement universal health care given the increased role of the federal government in the lives of its citizenry.

    I will expound upon the implications and benefits of such a proposal when it isn't 3:15 in the morning.

    ReplyDelete
  18. My faith tells me that A.) we should take care of one another, healing the sick whenever possible and to be generous with our wealth because it is all a gift from God and B.) that we should be good stewards of our body, which would imply that we are responsible for our own healthcare. I don't think there is a definite Christian stance on the healthcare bill, just as there is no definite Christian stance on which political party you should belong to.

    ReplyDelete